If at first listen The Roads Outgrown doesn't sound like a cohesive album, you can take solace in the fact that it is not supposed to. Think of this as an in-between release for the immensely popular Irish band (though only moderately so over here) bridging 2000's For the Birds with a pending new record to be released by Anti. The songs here are from sundry origins some live, others recorded in different studios by different people and many have popped up on compilations or as B-sides released in Ireland but not available in North America. The band has updated the Waterboys' approach of packing the electric guitar and the fiddle when going into the studio though without the obvious Celtic overtones and achieves gripping dynamics with clashing guitar chords and a barrage of lyrics all juxtaposed with seductive violin (most especially on "Sickbeds" and the almost nine-and-a-half minute live version of "Fitzcarraldo"). Other stand out tracks include alternate versions of "Lay Me Down" and "Headlong" off For the Birds, and a studio version of Will Oldham's "New Partner" previously available as a live track on Breadcrumb Trail.
(Overcoat)Frames
The Roads Outgrown
BY Brent HagermanPublished Oct 1, 2003