Ipecacs Greg Werckman says it best about tribute records in his brief liner notes: "why would I want to hear some crappy band ruin a song by a band that I loved? But he also nails it with, "if there is any artist that has never gotten the recognition they deserve, its the Melvins. Unquestionably, the Melvins are one of the greatest, most influential (no Melvins = no Nirvana) and most unrecognised bands in music history. And, in tribute, Fractured Transmitter has assembled a number of "crappy bands, such as the Dillinger Escape Plan, Pig Destroyer, Mastodon, Strapping Young Lad, Eyehategod and numerous others to pay homage. Being composed of aggressive artists, most of the songs covered are drawn from the Melvins metal/rock cannon, and while thats only one facet of the Melvins (lets not forgot their penchant for experimentation, pop, noise and pissing off everyone just because), considering those involved, its enough. Dillinger rip through the thunderous "Honeybucket, adding computerised-like accents, an underlying guitar line and tightening things up, while Strapping Young Lad annihilate "Zodiac, which is one of the few tracks to feature a vocalist not trying to do "the voice (as there is only one Buzz), letting Devin truly go off at the end. Other standouts include Mastodon ("The Bit), Meatjack ("Shevil), Isis/Agoraphobic Nosebleed ("Boris) and, oddly, Mare ("Nightgoat), who truly capture the playful/jerkiness of the Melvins with a drum, vocal track thatll piss off everyone tuning in for the big metal names. Nicely done.
(Fractured Transmitter)Various
We Reach: The Music of the Melvins
BY Chris GramlichPublished Oct 1, 2005